Do Cyclists Break Traffic Rules More Often Than Drivers? Research Suggests Otherwise

05. 11. 2026, Bezpečnost

Cyclists run red lights, ignore traffic signs and behave as though the rules don’t apply to them. We regularly hear complaints like these in debates about urban transport. But are cyclists really less law-abiding than car drivers? Research does not support this widespread stereotype. It also shows that compliance with traffic rules is closely linked to the design of transport infrastructure.

One interesting comparison comes from a study funded by the Florida Department of Transportation. Researchers equipped 100 cyclists with cameras, GPS devices and other sensors, monitoring their behaviour over approximately 2,000 hours of cycling. The study also assessed the behaviour of motorists whom the cyclists encountered on the road.

The results showed that cyclists complied with traffic rules in approximately 88% of observed situations, compared with 85% for motorists. While the difference is not particularly dramatic, it certainly does not support the idea that cyclists are significantly less disciplined road users.

Of course, the study does not suggest that all cyclists obey the rules, nor can its findings automatically be applied to Czech roads. It does, however, demonstrate that stereotypes about cyclists do not necessarily reflect reality when actual road behaviour is observed.

Traffic Rules Are Broken Almost Three Times as Often Where Cycling Infrastructure Is Absent
An even more interesting finding came from a large Danish study conducted in 2019, which observed the behaviour of more than 28,500 cyclists at traffic-light-controlled intersections. Researchers recorded nine types of traffic violations, including running red lights, making incorrect turns and cycling on pavements.

The study found that approximately 5% of cyclists committed one of the observed violations on roads with dedicated cycling infrastructure. Where cycle paths or cycle lanes were absent, the figure rose to almost 14% — nearly three times as high.

Although observational research alone cannot establish a direct causal relationship, these findings suggest just how important the design of public space can be. When people cycling have a clearly designated, safe and intuitive space in which to ride, they are more likely to follow the rules. Where cycling infrastructure is lacking, they may instead find themselves in situations where they choose alternatives to the prescribed route or behaviour.

“For more than ten years, I have studied the behaviour of cyclists, filmed intersections and used direct observation to track and calculate how many people violate Danish traffic laws. And the result absolutely blew my mind. It’s only 6%. The perception of cyclist behaviour around the world is completely disconnected from reality,” says Mikael Colville-Andersen, a Danish urban mobility expert.

According to Colville-Andersen, well-designed infrastructure is the key to encouraging compliance with traffic rules. “Amsterdam has lots of amazing spaces dedicated to cyclists, but it lacks design thinking and planning. As a result, more cyclists deviate from traffic regulations because they are trying to work around poor design.”

AutoMat’s Research Also Confirms the Impact of Infrastructure on Cyclists’ Behaviour

Similar conclusions were reached by a 2023 study conducted by our Sustainable Urbanism Lab. Over 50 hours of observation at ten locations across Prague, combined with three focus group discussions, the research team examined how people cycle in areas with varying levels of cycling infrastructure quality.

“The findings confirm that high-quality infrastructure minimises problematic behaviour. However, cycle paths and cycle lanes must be continuous, intuitive and genuinely useful to cyclists. If the legal option is not also practical, cyclists will ignore it,” the research report states.

One example is the exit from the Vltava riverfront near the Mánes building, where cyclists often choose an alternative route across a pedestrian crossing or along the pavement to avoid waiting several minutes at traffic lights.

The study also found that behaviour which appears dangerous at first glance does not necessarily pose an actual risk to others.

“One surprising finding is that even cycling that appears risky, such as navigating an intersection where turning is difficult, can in fact be entirely safe. […] However, this should not be confused with reckless cycling, which also occurs,” AutoMat notes.

Based on their observations, the research team proposed 87 measures to improve Prague’s cycling infrastructure.

Why Do Cyclists Break Traffic Rules in the First Place?

Another interesting perspective comes from a study conducted in Montreal, Canada, which analysed responses from more than 1,300 cyclists. It found that the reasons people break traffic rules are not always as straightforward as they might seem.

Some respondents, for example, reported feeling safer in certain traffic situations when deviating from the rules. This might involve trying to avoid conflicts with motor vehicles or responding to a poorly designed intersection.

Of course, this does not mean that breaking traffic rules is acceptable. However, it reminds us that road behaviour is not simply a matter of individual responsibility. It is also shaped by the environment in which people travel.

Well-designed infrastructure should be not only safe but also intuitive. When traffic arrangements reflect how people naturally move through a space, they are more likely to be respected.

Where There’s Good Infrastructure, Things Work Better

Not All Traffic Violations Pose the Same Risk

Discussions about traffic violations often overlook another important factor: their potential consequences. Running a red light is a traffic offence regardless of whether someone is riding a bicycle or driving a car. However, when it comes to the potential danger posed to others, the weight of the vehicle, its speed and the energy of a possible collision all play a crucial role.

While a bicycle typically weighs a few dozen kilograms or less, a passenger car commonly weighs more than a tonne. Moreover, kinetic energy increases rapidly with speed, as does the potential severity of a collision. This is not a reason to overlook traffic violations committed by cyclists. It is, however, a reason to distinguish between breaking a rule and the level of risk that doing so poses to others.

The scale of these differences is also illustrated by Czech traffic collision data concerning pavements and tram stop islands, analysed by AutoMat. Between January 2007 and the end of May 2026, 46 pedestrians were killed in collisions on pavements or tram stop islands in Czechia. Of these, 45 died in collisions caused by car drivers, while just one died in a collision caused by a cyclist — a ratio of 45 to 1.

A substantial difference is also evident in the figures for serious injuries. During the same period, 253 collisions on pavements and tram stop islands resulted in serious injuries to pedestrians. Of these, 208 were caused by car drivers and 45 by cyclists. Motorists therefore caused more than four times as many of these collisions.

Of course, these figures do not mean that cycling on pavements is risk-free or that reckless behaviour by cyclists should be ignored. They do, however, demonstrate why it is important to consider the actual consequences of collisions when assessing the risks posed by different road users. In terms of the number of the most serious outcomes, motor vehicles pose a substantially greater danger to pedestrians on pavements and tram stop islands.

What About Cyclists in Czechia?

In the Czech Republic, we do not yet have a comparable, representative study systematically examining how frequently cyclists and motorists break traffic rules in everyday traffic. Although police collision statistics record the causes of crashes and who was responsible for them, they do not tell us how often different groups of road users violate traffic rules during their daily journeys. We therefore cannot simply use collision figures to determine which group is more law-abiding.

International findings must also be interpreted with caution. Individual studies examine different types of violations, use different methodologies and take place under different traffic conditions.

“Of course I’d prefer to use cycle paths if I could, but either I’d have to make a huge detour across Prague, and I simply don’t have that much time, or there just aren’t any cycle paths. So yes, I admit that I sometimes cycle on the pavement, but I make sure not to put anyone at risk. And when there’s no other option, I ride on the road, but when traffic is heavy, I try to avoid it because it’s really dangerous,” says Jana (63), one of the participants in Lucie Šroglová’s master’s thesis, Between Joy and Fear for One’s Life: The Emotional Geography of Women Cyclists in Prague. Her words capture the everyday reality faced by people cycling in Prague.

Safer Streets Benefit Everyone

So what can we conclude from these studies? Above all, there is no good reason to automatically assume that cyclists are less law-abiding than car drivers. The available observational evidence does not support such a generalisation. At the same time, it suggests that the way we design streets and intersections can influence not only safety but also people’s willingness and ability to follow traffic rules.

In fact, the division between cyclists, motorists and pedestrians is largely artificial. According to a Czech Kantar survey conducted for the Dám respekt initiative in 2022, 84% of people who cycle also drive motor vehicles. Most of us therefore take on different roles in traffic — sometimes behind the wheel, sometimes on a bicycle and sometimes on foot.

With each of these roles, our responsibility towards others also changes. Traffic rules and consideration for others apply to everyone, but the degree of responsibility should also reflect the level of risk our actions may create. The heavier and faster the vehicle we operate, the more serious the consequences of our mistakes can be.

Instead of endlessly debating which group of road users behaves worse, we should focus on creating conditions that make safe and considerate behaviour as easy as possible. Segregated cycle paths, safe intersections and clear, intuitive street design are not simply about making cycling more convenient. They can help make traffic more predictable and safer for everyone.

Sources and Further Reading:

Florida Department of Transportation (2017): Bicycle Safety: A Study of Bicyclists and Motorists in Florida. Výzkum chování cyklistů a motoristů s využitím kamer a senzorů.
Danish Road Directorate (2019): Cyclist Behaviour at Signalised Intersections. Pozorovací studie více než 28 500 cyklistů. Studie v PDF.
Městem na kole (2025): Cyclists and Traffic Offenses: What’s Really True?
Cykloetiketa
Lucie Šroglová: Mezi radostí a strachem o život: Emoční geografie cyklistek v Praze ( Sociální geografie a regionální rozvoj, Přírodovědecká fakulta UK)
AutoMat zkoumal chování cyklistů*ek Praze. Navrhuje přes 80 zlepšení infrastruktury

Líbí se vám, co v AutoMatu děláme? Podpořte nás a nakrmte AutoMat jakoukoliv částkou. Děkujeme!

Nakrmte AutoMat

Podpořte nás a staňte se tak členy Klubu přátel AutoMatu!

V dalším kroku budete přesměrováni na platební bránu.

V dalším kroku budete přesměrováni na platební bránu.

V dalším kroku uvidíte údaje potřebné k založení platby v bance.

měsíčně 1000,- Kč

Děkujeme mnohokrát za Vaší podporu, moc si ji vážíme.

Prosíme, nastavte si platbu ve své bance podle následujících údajů, abychom poznali, že jde o podporu od Vás.

  • ve prospěch účtu: 2400063333/2010
  • částka: [amount]
  • variabilní symbol: [variable_symbol]
  • vybraná frekvence plateb: [freq]
Něco se nepovedlo
Zpět do formuláře